The Battle of the Five Armies starts-in immediately with action and seldom slows down. If it feels like this is an unusually fast-paced film, it's because it is. However, at no time did I feel overwhelmed in trying to keep track of all the goings-on. And I can also assure you that despite such great battles as Helms Deep and Minas Tirith (Battle of the Pelennor Fields), the Battle For Erebor will show few similarities. Yes, Jackson achieved a uniqueness in all three gigantic pitched battles throughout the entire saga, which I found to be impressive in furtherance of each battle's high entertainment value. This film's central battle won't disappoint.
As much as I was NOT a fan of the focus on Lake Town's political intrigue "filler" in The Desolation of Smaug, I found the repeated appearances by the weasel Alfrid in this film to be an eye-rolling opportunity again and again. Moments of levity during an intense battle worked perfectly between Legolas and Gimli at Helms Deep. It didn't work here.
The Battle of the Five Armies takes place at a point in Tolkien's book that was for all intents and purposes, glossed over in a few pages. However, Jackson seized the initiative to bring not only the original greedy orc army into the fold, but the forces of the Angband orcs and the sheer malevolence of Sauron himself who wished to (after winning the battle) use Erebor as a staging point for an invasion of the entirety of the West. This was a plot point I took-to with relish, because it makes complete sense in the expansive conflict that was the Lord of the Rings saga.
In keeping with the use of the appendices to the Lord of the Rings, Jackson included the setting (not explained in Tolkien's "Hobbit") of the fortress Dol Guldur and the rescue of Gandalf therefrom by the White Counsel -- Elrond, Galadriel and Saruman. This is a scene in which the extremely formidable talents of those age-old warriors are on display against the Nine Black Riders and eventually, Sauron himself. Visually, it was as hectic as it was triumphant. I have no compunctions in telling you how much of a treat this part was to watch.
Now, back to Erebor... After bravely killing Smaug, Bard is able to marshal the Lake Town folk as he brings them to the steps of the Lonely Mountain itself. This was out of necessity as the town was mostly destroyed in Smaug's rage -- another visually impressive set piece. Unfortunately, elvish King Thranduil has also marched an army on Erebor, not out of friendship towards the dwarves in their time of need, but out of greed. His interests begin and end with a case of bright gems, despite the protests of his son Legolas and fellow elvish warrior Tauriel.
The dominant focus of the film for me, was the magnificent performance of the troubled newly-crowned King Thorin. Alluded to in The Desolation of Smaug, was the often-underestimated effect that such a treasure horde can have on the mind of a mortal. Add to this, the poisonous effect that Smaug's ever-present malice had on the entire realm within the Lonely Mountain. Further compounding the disturbed Thorin, is the sheer weight of the power and influence he suddenly wields. He trusts no one and begins treating his once-friends as nothing more than servants, if not slaves. Richard Armitage will hopefully garner an Oscar nomination for his dizzying and powerful portrayal of a mad king.
In fact, Armitage performed his paranoia and power-madness so well, that when he eventually breaks it and rallies his fellow dwarves head-long into battle, it rivals Gandalf's arrival at the climax of the Battle of Helms Deep in The Two Towers. Simply excellent writing is exemplified when you literally want to cheer for a character's actions on screen. And you'll want to do A LOT of cheering as every individual protagonist gets his and her chance to shine throughout the battle, which was choreographed and balanced beautifully by the film's writers.
Yes, I am a diehard fan of this trilogy, but -- especially owing to how it was expanded beyond the simple lighthearted tale it was -- I don't think you can blame me. I encourage you to read the appendices to the Lord of the Rings and therein, you'll see just how fascinating the dwarvish culture is, as well as how much Tolkien unfortunately neglected enriching their history in his story. I simply have to add what is one of my favorite quotes (okay, paraphrases) from the entire saga: "if more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world." -- Thorin Oakenshield
Free Download Part 1
Free Download Part 2


